X's AI-Powered News Feature: A Recipe for Ambition and Chaos

X has recently introduced a new AI-powered news feature called "Stories," which aims to provide users with a curated summary of current news and discussions on the platform. The feature, powered by X's own chatbot, Grok, relies solely on user comments related to the news stories rather than the original articles themselves. While this approach is ambitious, it also raises concerns about the potential for misinformation and manipulation.

According to X's owner, Elon Musk, Grok analyzes "tens of thousands of X posts to create a summary of the news," with the goal of delivering "the most accurate and up-to-date information and citing the most important sources." However, relying exclusively on user comments for news summaries carries significant risks. Comments can misrepresent news, take information out of context, or deliberately manipulate the narrative.

The feature has already encountered issues, ranging from minor glitches in summarizing news to the creation of entirely fabricated stories due to AI misinterpretation of user comments. Transparency in the process of selecting and utilizing user comments for news summaries is likely to be a significant challenge for X.

Despite the potential pitfalls, the concept behind "Stories" could be a unique selling point in the highly competitive news market if executed effectively. If X can successfully summarize user comments in a balanced manner while providing visibility to the original sources and potentially driving more traffic to them, the feature could prove to be an interesting addition to the platform.

Given the current state of available technology and X's track record in the AI domain, the successful implementation of this product seems to be a distant reality. The fact that X is under the control of a single individual, Elon Musk, who has repeatedly demonstrated his willingness to exert targeted influence on the dissemination of news on the platform in recent months, further complicates matters.

As X rolls out "Stories" to premium users via the web and iOS, it remains to be seen whether the feature will evolve into an innovative news product or devolve into a formula for chaos. The success of this AI-driven news curation will depend on X's ability to address the inherent challenges of relying on user-generated content while ensuring the accuracy, transparency, and credibility of the news summaries it provides.

twitter.com/XEng/status/1786463531505799186