Should transgender men be able to compete in women's sports? 💭
NOPE. I'm comfortable with the distinction that gender is a social construct. It's a new concept and not of my generation but i can adapt to that np. But that's stepping into biology and it's pretty clear it all breaks down at that level. Just combat sports alone. Pretty damn sure any pro female mma fighter would absolutely body me. But your average male born athlete destroys the average female born one 🤷♂️ . Damn lens just got political. Also I think it's transgender WOMEN you mean. Transgender men are born women, or at least that's what i think are the rules.
Has any transgender women excelled in physically intensive men's sports like soccer, rugby, football?
The women in sports should be asked this question, and I won't be surprised if the majority say no.
Of course not lol men have denser bones, bigger muscles, taller, different bone shape, bigger hearts, bigger lungs, way more testosterone, less fat tissue, higher rate of hypertrophy etc etc. Totally unfair to any woman who has trained her whole life to achieve her dreams. If you could make them equal somehow then it'd be fine, but you just can't. You can't beat nature. You are what you are.
No. Men are genetically much faster and stronger. An average professional male athlete can decide to identify as a women and go dominate that sport in women's division. Honestly, surprised this is even question in our society.
What about deleting genres and just doing the competition? Then we won’t focus on the ethic polemic but on the sport (which is what it really matters, right?)
Women should do women sports and men do men sports. There are only 2 genders; men and women
Short (and permanent) answer: No.
It’s unfair to the other drug-free participants.